Can a Judge Deny a Divorce and Issue Marriage Counseling: 2 Times

Can a judge deny a divorce and issue marriage counseling? This is a question that many couples are asking themselves. Yes, Judges can deny the divorce. Though it depends on the state laws.

In most cases, the judge goes through the intent of the parties. If they are ready to divorce in their intention, then the judge rarely issues marriage counselling. However, in some cases, judges initiate issuing marriage counseling.

Here in this article, you will know the 2 possible circumstances when a judge denies a divorce and issues marriage counselling.

can a judge deny a divorce and issue marriage counseling

Can a Judge Deny a Divorce and Issue Marriage Counseling: 2 Times


#1. When there is the possibility of saving marriage:

Marriage is a legal as well as a social contract between two people. Once this contract is signed, both the husband and wife are bound by law to follow the terms of the agreement. A divorce can only happen when both parties agree to dissolve the Marriage.

If the judge believes the marriage can be saved, he/she can order both parties to attend counseling. Therapy can be done individually or together, depending on each party’s preference.

There is no law to govern this issue. It totally depends on the discretionary power of the judges. Though in most states, Judges don’t exercise this practice.

In some cases, one spouse may want a divorce, but the other doesn’t. Suppose the spouse who doesn’t want a divorce can convince the judge that there is a possibility to save the Marriage. In that case, the judge may deny the divorce and order both parties to attend marriage counselling.

The goal of marriage counselling is to help the couple communicate better, work through their differences and come to a resolution. If the couple can resolve their issues, they can continue their marriage.

If the therapy is successful, the divorce will be denied, and the couple can stay married. However, if therapy is unsuccessful, the divorce will be granted, and the couple can go their separate ways.

#2. If there are such minor children:

If minor children are involved, the couple’s divorce may have a long-term effect on their lives. Divorce can be very traumatic for children and can cause them emotional damage.

So, the judge may feel it is best for the children if their parents stay together.  In such cases, the judge can deny the divorce and order marriage counselling to try and save the Marriage for the sake of the children.

For example, if an infant is 6 months old, the judge may believe that it is not in the child’s best interest to grow up in a broken family. The judge may deny the divorce and order marriage counselling to give the couple a chance to work on their relationship for their children’s sake.

It is important to note that judges will not force couples to stay together if there is abuse or violence in the Marriage. In such cases, the safety of both parties and any children involved should always come first.

If therapy is successful, it can provide a stable and loving environment for the children to grow up in. However, if therapy is unsuccessful, the divorce will still be granted, and appropriate arrangements will be made for the children’s well-being.

Judges rarely exercise this power and usually allow the divorce to proceed if both parties agree. This practice is also not common in all states, as laws vary from state to state.

Don’t expect a judge to be a therapist

Just because a judge can order marriage counselling doesn’t mean he is a therapist. The judge’s job is to ensure the couple has a fair divorce settlement. He is not there to save marriages.

Judges know the laws, and they give orders according to them. His or her attitude can be very impartial and is often seen as cold or unemotional. On the other hand, a professional counsellor is someone who can help you understand your emotions and can offer guidance on how to work through your problems.

So, if you hope that the judge will be a therapist and save your marriage, you will probably be disappointed. If you are having difficulties in your marriage, it is best to seek out professional counselling.

Can the court order marriage counselling? It was answered by Mary E. Ramos, Divorce Lawyer in Houston. I hope the below video discussion will help you:

FAQs on Can a Judge Deny a Divorce and Issue Marriage Counseling


Can a Texas judge order counseling?

In Texas, family courts have much leeway when ordering counselling for parties involved in a divorce or child custody case. Judges will often order counselling as a way to help the parties resolve their differences and come to an agreement about their future.

Counselling can also be ordered to help the parties deal with the stress of the divorce process. Counselling may be ordered in some situations to keep the children from being hurt by the fights between their parents.

Suppose you are involved in a divorce or child custody case in Texas. In that case, speaking with an experienced family law attorney is crucial to learn more about your rights and options.

Is marriage counselling required before divorce in Florida?

State law in Florida says couples who want to get a divorce must go through a marriage counselling program. The program, which both spouses must complete, consists of four hours of counselling with a licensed mental health counsellor, marriage and family therapist, clinical social worker, or psychiatrist.

The counselling aims to explore the possibility of reconciling the marriage. If the couple can agree on the divorce terms, they may waive the counselling requirement. But if the couple can’t agree, they each have to do an extra four hours of counselling.  Only after completing the required counselling will the court grant a divorce.

While some couples may view mandatory counselling as an unnecessary hurdle, it provides an essential opportunity for couples to reflect on their decision and explore all options for saving their marriage.

Can a judge deny a divorce based on religion?

In the United States, divorce is generally seen as a legal matter that the courts should decide. However, there have been some instances where judges have denied divorces based on religious grounds.

For example, in 2014, a judge in Louisiana refused to grant a divorce to a couple because they belonged to the Catholic Church, which does not recognise divorce. Even though this ruling was overturned on appeal, it shows how religious beliefs and the law can sometimes clash.

In general, a judge probably wouldn’t deny a divorce just because one or both of the people involved are religious.

The Supreme Court has ruled that the constitutional right to freedom of religion includes the right to practice or not practice any religion. This right trumps any state laws that would favour one religion over another.

As such, while a judge may consider religious beliefs when deciding on a divorce, it is unlikely that religion would be used as a basis for denying a divorce.

Why can’t I get a divorce on my own?

To get a divorce in the United States, a married couple must first file a petition with the court. The petition must be signed by both spouses and include grounds for divorce. Once the petition is filed, the court will set a hearing date.

At the hearing, both spouses will have an opportunity to present their cases. After hearing both sides, the judge will make a final decision. If the judge grants the divorce, the couple will be legally divorced and will no longer be married.

Many couples would like to get a divorce but cannot do so on their own. In these cases, one spouse may not want to get divorced, or the couple may not be able to agree on grounds for divorce.

In some states, such as California, couples can get a divorce without going to court if they can reach an agreement on all aspects of their divorce, including property division and child custody. Even in these states, it’s best to talk to a lawyer before going through with a divorce.

Can a divorced spouse remarry within his or her religion?

In most religions, marriage is considered to be a sacred institution. It is usually not regarded as appropriate for divorced individuals to remarry.

This is based on the belief that marriage is a lifetime commitment and that divorce represents a failure to uphold that commitment. People who have been divorced may be able to get married again if they get an annulment from their religious leaders.

An annulment essentially nullifies the original marriage, allowing the individuals to be considered unmarried in the eyes of their religion. However, annulments are typically only granted in cases where the marriage was never consummated or where there was some other impediment to the marriage that prevented it from being valid.

As a result, divorced individuals who wish to remarry within their religion generally have few options available to them.

Conclusion

So, a judge may choose to deny a divorce and issue marriage counselling based on state laws and circumstances. This can happen if the judge feels there is still a chance for the couple to save their marriage. If minor children are involved, the judge may feel it is better for them if their parents stay together.

About Shakir Ahmed

Head of the editorial team. I hold a Bachelor of Laws (LL.B) from UoL. Written hundreds of articles on divorce, child custody, employment and other human rights law topics for blogs and websites worldwide. Worked 6 years as a relationship development trainer. For any communication regarding any legal matter, please feel free to email me at shakir@lawyersnlaws.com

Leave a Comment